How the FBI Is Using T-Shirts, Online Shopping Accounts, and Tattoos to Track Down Protesters

How the FBI Is Using T-Shirts, Online Shopping Accounts, and Tattoos to Track Down Protesters


The phrase “Keep the Immigrants, Deport the Racists” appears all over Etsy. Variants on the stating are proudly emblazoned on espresso cups, pins, leggings, and even needlepoint. T-shirts with  Black Ability fists bursting through the midsection or with thoughtfully intended fonts or squished American flags all have the concept, as well. But only a single of these products and solutions showcased the slogan on a sky-blue shirt. A girl included in the demonstrations adhering to the death of George Floyd purchased and wore that pretty shirt to a protest in Philadelphia—and even though it seems to be just a generic slogan tee, it set off a extended winding chain of occasions that ultimately resulted in her arrest. A grievance submitted by the FBI facts how the business painstakingly tracked down Lore-Elisabeth Blumenthal, who was needed for allegedly environment fire to a law enforcement car or truck (Seamus Hughes, deputy director of the system on extremism at George Washington College, initially broke the scenario down on Twitter right before deleting his thread mainly because his “Twitter notifications were a cesspool,” he instructed me). The situation peels back the quite a few techniques social media posts, on the internet purchasing habits, and even the outfits we consider of as somewhat anonymous can be used to sniff out particular person protesters.

On Might 30th, Blumenthal went to a protest in Philadelphia donning a light-weight blue T-shirt, a backpack, blue denims, and gloves. A individual matching this description was found in pictures and footage filmed from Television set news helicopters seizing a burning piece of wooden from a barricade and shoving it into a police SUV, which was eaten up by flames times later.

Whilst there was information protection of the scene, moreover a online video uploaded to Vimeo, investigators ended up unable to identify the identity of their suspect—until they hopped on Instagram. There, one beginner photographer shared 500 pictures from the Philadelphia protest, some of which included the particular person of curiosity, with the FBI. From these pics, the textual content on the T-shirt—“Keep the Immigrants, Deport the Racists”—and the peace indicator tattoo on the inside of the person’s arm had been the two visible. All the FBI definitely necessary was the T-shirt, which was traced back again to a shop on Etsy. In the shop’s responses section, a consumer from Philadelphia with the display screen name “Xx Mv” thanked the vendor for speedy delivery.

From there, the FBI adopted a string of internet sites exactly where Blumenthal was established up. Her Etsy web page led investigators to her profile on Poshmark, a secondary marketplace for clothes, which gave brokers a genuine name that matched with a LinkedIn profile. The LinkedIn profile shown out Blumenthal’s location of perform, exactly where investigators observed video clips of a masseuse with the identical peace signal tattoo, as nicely as a phone amount and corresponding tackle. The FBI subpoenaed data from the Etsy shop—which located the T-shirt was transported to the similar deal with. An arrest warrant was issued and Blumenthal was taken into custody. 

This is not the initially time in the latest months the FBI has used tattoos to establish protesters. Tattoo artists all around the nation have posted warnings on social media that investigators are coming to stores with photos of protesters’ ink in hopes of matching them to a consumer. Soon after Grand Avenue Tattoo reopened immediately after coronavirus lockdown in Minnesota, two FBI brokers pulled up to the shop and asked artist Ransom Bennett to establish designs. Bennett at first refused, but said the agents even now held out a photograph for him to glance at. “It was an extremely pixelated photo with a tattoo on the inside of the forearm that was difficult to make out,” Bennett instructed me. He stated to the investigator that determining the proprietor would be impossible—the picture would render producing a positive ID “irresponsible,” in his terms.” But not all pics of tattoos are so illegible.



Supply connection